Essential Data from Particle Measurement

Comparing Particle Detection Methods

In the manufacturing industry, maintaining optimal air quality is vital for worker health and production efficiency. Precise particle measurement is one of the most effective ways to monitor air quality. This article delves into the significance of particle measurement, the technologies involved, and their practical applications in manufacturing settings.
Airborne particles, both large and small, significantly impact indoor air quality (IAQ). These particles can come from various sources, including industrial processes, combustion, and natural origins. In manufacturing, activities such as welding, cutting, and machining release a substantial amount of particulate matter into the air. Monitoring and controlling these particles is essential for complying with health regulations, improving worker safety, and maintaining product quality.

Technologies for Particle Measurement

Photometers, optical particle counters (OPCs), and condensation particle counters (CPCs) each provide real-time measurement of airborne particles, but they differ in their sensitivity to specific characteristics like size, mass, and refractive index. The performance of these technologies varies, with distinctions in size ranges and maximum number concentrations, particularly between OPCs and CPCs. Table 1 highlights these performance differences, while Table 2 outlines typical applications for each technology, offering guidance on their best uses in manufacturing environments.

Table1: Real-Time Particle Measurement Technologies

	Photometer	OPC	CPC
Typical Size Range	0.1 to 10 μg	0.3 to 20 μg	0.02 to 1.0 μg
Measures Particle Mass	Yes	No	No
Measures Particle Size	Yes²	Yes	No
Detects Single Particles	No	Yes	Yes
Typical Mass Concentration Range	0.01 to 100 mg/m³	N/A	N/A
Typical Number Concentration, Upper Limit	N/A	2 x 10⁶ Particles/ft³ 70 Particles/cm³	1.5 x 10¹⁰ Particles/ft³ 500,000 Particles/cm³

Table 2: Applications (Best Practices)

	Photometer	OPC	CPC
Indoor Air Quality - Convetional Studies	Good	Good	Excellent
Indoor Air Quality - Ultrafine Particle Tracking	Poor	N/A	Excellent
Industrial Workplace Monitoring	Excellent	Poor	Excellent¹
Outdoor Environmental Monitoring	Good	Good	Excellent¹
Emissions Monitoring	Excellent	Poor	Good
Respirator Fit Testing	Excellent	Poor	Excellent
Filter Testing	Excellent	Excellent	Excellent
Cleanroom Monitoring	Poor	Excellent	Excellent

¹Health effects of ultrafine particles (below 0.1 μm) are not completely understood, though research suggests that they may cause the greatest harm. There are currently no established exposure limits or governmental regulations specifically addressing ultrafines.
²DustTrak DRX Aerosol Monitor

Photometers

Photometers measure particle concentrations by detecting light scattered by airborne particles, effective for particles ranging from 0.1 to 10 micrometers in diameter. Photometers use a light source and a detector to measure the intensity of light scattered by particles. This method provides real-time data and is valuable for continuous monitoring in manufacturing environments.
Advantages:

Real-Time Data: Continuous monitoring for immediate detection of changes in particle concentration.
Versatility: Effective for various particle sizes, suitable for multiple industrial applications.

Limitations:

Calibration Needs: Regular calibration against known standards is required for accuracy. However DustTrak users have the flexibility to adjust sensitivity for specific aerosols.
Environmental Sensitivity: Humidity and temperature can affect readings, requiring controlled conditions. However, the DustTrak Aerosol Monitor includes built-in user calibration and an auto-zero function to address environmental factors.

Condensation Particle Counters (CPCs)

CPCs detect ultrafine particles as small as a few nanometers. They condense vapor onto particles to enlarge them, making them detectable by optical methods. This technology is essential for capturing data on the smallest particles that other methods might miss.

Advantages:

Ultrafine Particle Detection: Measures particles down to nanometer size, crucial for detecting hazardous ultrafine particles.
High Sensitivity: Provides high sensitivity and accuracy, ideal for cleanroom environments and high-precision manufacturing processes.

Limitations:

Complexity: More complex and expensive than other particle measurement technologies.
Maintenance: Requires regular maintenance and calibration to ensure accuracy.

Optical Particle Counters (OPCs)

OPCs use a laser to detect and count particles by measuring the light they scatter. This technology is highly effective for a wide range of particle sizes and is often used in cleanroom environments and for detailed IAQ assessments.

Advantages:

Wide Range Detection: Effective for particles from a few micrometers to several tens of micrometers.
Detailed Analysis: Provides detailed size distribution data, useful for comprehensive air quality assessments.

Limitations:

Initial Cost: Higher initial investment compared to simpler photometers.
Maintenance and Calibration: Requires regular upkeep to maintain accuracy.

Practical Applications in Manufacturing

Implementing particle measurement in manufacturing involves several steps to ensure accurate data collection:

Identify Sources of Particles: Begin by identifying the primary sources of particulate matter within the facility, including specific machines, processes, or materials. This helps in placing monitoring equipment strategically.
Select Appropriate Instruments: Choose instruments based on the types and sizes of particles you need to measure. For example, a CPC for ultrafine particles from welding fumes, or an OPC/photometer for general dust.
Regular Monitoring and Maintenance: Continuously monitor air quality with the selected instruments, ensuring regular maintenance and calibration for accurate readings.
Data Analysis and Response: Analyze collected data to identify trends and potential problem areas. If high particulate concentrations are detected, investigate sources and implement control measures like improved ventilation or filtration systems.

Learn More About Aerosol and Dust Monitoring

Article based on TSI Application Note ITI-075: Getting Data You Need With Particle Measurements. Reprinted from Indoor Environment Connections, November 2000, Volume 2, Issue 1

Related Resources

Filter Testing of materials for masks and respirators

Filter Testing Determines Mask and Respirator Efficacy

TSI’s Automatic Filter Tester helped ensure respirator safety during COVID-19 pandemic. By meeting international standards, it aided in providing effective PPE, crucial for protecting medical staff.